The 2026 contest winners are inGrand Prize, People's Choice and Most Creative, all crowned.

Creepy Pumpkin Carving Ideas

151 carving ideas to explore

Creepy is quieter than scary. Nothing on this page roars at you. It just watches.

Stitches the Creepy Pumpkin FaceThe Blank-Eyed Creepy PumpkinCreepy Crawler the Spider Pumpkin

Creepy looks to try

Creepy is quieter than scary. Nothing on this page roars at you. It just watches.

Stitched and sewn faces

A mouth or eye sewn shut with crude stitches. Cut the mouth as a thin slit and scrape short bars across it for the stitches, leaving the skin between them. The uneven spacing is the point, so do not measure.

8 designs in the gallery

Stitches the Creepy Pumpkin FaceSutures the Creepy Pumpkin FaceSewn Shut the Creepy Pumpkin LanternStitchmouth the Creepy Jack-O-Lantern pumpkin carving

Blank stares and hollow eyes

Wide, empty eyes with no pupils and a small or missing mouth. Cut the eyes larger than feels right and perfectly round. The lack of expression is what unsettles people.

16 designs in the gallery

The Blank-Eyed Creepy PumpkinChuckles the Creepy Clown pumpkin carvingThe Watching Spooky Tree PumpkinThe Hollow Scream Pumpkin

Crawling things

Spiders, hands and tentacles emerging from the pumpkin. Carve the body as an opening and the legs as scrapes that trail off the edge, or push real twigs into holes for legs that stand out from the surface.

21 designs in the gallery

Creepy Crawler the Spider PumpkinTango the Creepy Tarantula, a painted no-carve pumpkinThe Reaching Hand Lantern pumpkin carvingRaised Hand the Grim Reaper pumpkin carving
Good to know

Creepy pumpkin carving FAQ

How is creepy different from scary?
Scary is loud: fangs, demons, screaming faces. Creepy is quiet: a blank stare, a stitched mouth, a hand reaching out. Creepy pumpkins are usually simpler to carve because they rely on one unsettling detail instead of lots of teeth.
How do I make a pumpkin face unsettling?
Break one rule of a normal face. Make the eyes too far apart, too big or too empty. Remove the mouth, or sew it shut with scraped stitches. A single odd detail on an otherwise plain face is creepier than a whole monster.
What is a simple creepy design for a beginner?
Two large round eyes with no pupils and nothing else. Cut them through, light the pumpkin, and place it where it can be seen from the street. It takes ten minutes and people will cross the road.
Are the creepy pumpkin stencils free?
Yes. Enter your email on a linked stencil page to unlock its free printable PDF. Print on letter or A4 paper and adjust the scale to your pumpkin. Related stencils may differ from the inspiration images in this gallery.
Category leaderboard

How scary stacks up

Live rankings across all 12 categories, by unique visitors over the last 30 days. Updated as new carvings get submitted and viewed.

Most submissions
#5/ 12
678 carvings
10% of all submissions
Most viewed
#3/ 12πŸ₯‰
1,185 visitors
Unique visitors, last 30 days
Most views per carving
#4/ 12
1.7 per carving
Interest, not volume
The Patch Report

Fresh pumpkins, in your inbox.

The best new carvings, ideas worth stealing, and how-tos for carving season. Short, seasonal, and gone by November.

A short email during carving season. Unsubscribe anytime. See our privacy policy.